Episode #062 · Jacqueline Fisch
How To Write Your Story (Even When You're Afraid To Share It)
Writing about your own life sounds simple enough. After all, you know the story. But what happens when you start worrying about what other people will think, whether your experiences are worth sharing, or if you have anything meaningful to say?
One month after publishing The Multi-Hyphenate Dilemma, I'm joined by my former book coach, Jacqueline Fisch, to talk about the surprisingly personal work of writing a book. We explore why telling your story can feel harder than sharing your expertise, how to decide what belongs on the page, and why you don't need to have everything figured out before you begin.
Why Writing About Yourself Is Harder Than Writing for Clients
Jacqueline describes a framework-driven business book as the easier thing to write, because the framework sits at a distance from the person writing it. Personal story offers no such distance. It's hard for the exact reason it's worth doing.
She's blunt about where that leaves the current flood of machine-written books. "You can crank out a book with a couple clicks. It doesn't have a story and it doesn't have your story." Stories, she says, are how we connect and how we remember. Nobody remembers a framework.
I tell her about a businessman I once listened to who delivered a run of impressive percentages: eighty, ninety, three hundred and something. Hours later I couldn't have repeated a single one of them, or told you what they were meant to prove.
What she wants instead, including in business writing: "I want to know how you think and what shaped that." Not the conclusion. The thing underneath it.
Starting With Your Story Instead of Your Reader
Early in my own writing I read a book that told me to work out why my story would matter to a reader before I wrote a word of it. Every sentence after that came out clunky. Jacqueline says this is the thing she sees trip up almost everyone—treating the book as a product first, then "trying to fit your life experience into this little package."
Her own process runs in the other direction. "I start with the writer. What feels energizing for you? What is that story you keep coming back to?" She's particularly interested in the one a writer keeps skipping over while drafting. The audience gets sorted out later, and usually turns out to be someone resembling who the writer used to be.
On the nudge to write at all, she's unequivocal: "you have that nudge for a reason, full stop. It's not an accident. It's yours to write." The container can be a book, an essay, a Substack post.
Her instruction for beginning is start writing, which she admits is boring and predictable. No outline. One day a story, the next day a list of the stories you want to tell.
What It Took to Turn 50,000 Words Into a Book
Jacqueline has done National Novel Writing Month more than once. The first time, she hit the 50,000 words in 30 days. And then she didn't publish that book till almost 5 years later because she didn't know what it was.
Thirty thousand of those words came out. The finished book landed at 70,000, rearranged and rewritten. It had started as a book of life lessons, sat untouched for nearly a year, then got a surface pass for typos the following November.
What changed it was an editor telling her the stories were what made the advice land, and asking for more of them. Jacqueline had skimmed past the parts of her own history she assumed were ordinary—being laid off three times, moving fifteen times, moving countries with young children. "I'm like, oh, people actually care about this?" she recalled.
Then there's the question of everyone else on the page. Her position in the drafting stage is to put it all down: "You can decide later if you want to change names, identities to protect people."
When her own book reached a certain point, she sent a few family members the chapter they appeared in. "I wasn't asking permission," she said. "It was more like, FYI, this is what's in the book."
Is This Story Enough? What a Three-Star Review Surfaced
A three-star review for my own recent release landed the week before recording this interview, in the middle of a heavy vulnerability hangover. The review hit the place where I was already worried the book isn't prescriptive enough. Jacqueline names negativity bias, points out the reviewer has probably never written a book, and reminds me to count the readers who appreciated it without ever saying so.
Then she goes underneath it. "We're worried, is this story enough? Is this lesson enough? But the question is really, am I enough?" That, she says, is the inner work, and writing a book will change you in the doing of it.
During our conversation, I read a passage from Sue Monk Kidd about perfectionism as a response to fear, and ask how she handles high achievers who can't publish anything short of their capability. She's watched people start and never finish. Her filter is whether the book is complete and whether it will help someone.
Jacq also draws a line at timing—writing from the scar rather than the wound. How do you know? Notice your body while you revisit it, she says, because your body can't lie to you. "And if it still feels too fresh or not resolved, then you could pull it back."
What Jacqueline Means by Your Medicine on the Page
When I ask what success can reasonably look like for a writer at the outset, Jacqueline allows that sales and bestseller badges work as validation. Her own measure is smaller. "For me personally, the success is in the person who reaches out." A book sitting in your head can't speak to anyone.
The book she's writing now began the same way she tells everyone else to begin: almost no outline, the structure surfacing somewhere around chapter four or five. Its subject is energy, and what she's loosely calling medicine.
"I call it medicine because your medicine is in your pages." It's an energetic essence, not something you can edit in, and she can't yet say how it gets there.
So she's left with three questions at once: how to teach it, how to do it herself, how to live it. She knows what it looks like from the outside. It shows up when the chatter goes silent—is this good enough, what will my mother-in-law say—and there's just the writer and the page.
Then you read it back and feel something. "I don't care. It made me feel something." How do we get more of that onto the page?

Jacqueline Fisch
For 13 years, the words Jacqueline Fisch wrote lived under other people’s names. As a corporate and crisis communications leader, she knew how to make a message land. Writing her own story? That was uncomfortable at first. Since leaving corporate in 2017, she’s written four books and learned what every personal writer learns: it’s harder when there’s no framework to hide behind. Now she’s a writing mentor and founder of The Intuitive Writing School, helping founders and experienced professionals write the books, memoirs, and essays where their story carries the lesson. She hosts the How Women Write podcast and lives in Tampa, Florida.




